50 Government Street Rental Development
(James Bay Rezoning)

April 9, 2026
Housing & Development
Passed 7-2

Motion Summary

Victoria rejects 17-unit James Bay rental project 50 Government St. Council echoed concerns raised by city planning staff that the project was too big for the site and needed too many variances for things like setbacks.

Council Vote Breakdown

Reasons For

Staff and councillors noted the project requested excessive side and rear setback reductions (e.g., reducing a north side setback to 1.55 m and rear setback from 8.59 m to 5.65 m) on a narrow lot (17.06 m street frontage vs. the required 30 m). Stephen Hammond raised safety concerns regarding tight side setbacks, noting that narrow gaps between buildings make it difficult for firefighters to maneuver ground ladders during a blaze. Susan Kim questioned the actual affordability impact, pointing out that only two units were below-market—and specifically, only a studio unit was slated for deeper affordability rather than larger family-sized units. Mayor Marianne Alto emphasized that staff recommendations carry significant weight, and concerns over massing, outdoor space, and street presence had not been adequately addressed after multiple design iterations.

Reasons Against

Opposing councillors emphasized Victoria’s ongoing housing shortage and the need for new secured rental units. Dave Thompson expressed concern that outright declining the permit without specific instructions on how to amend the project wastes time and resources, unnecessarily delaying new housing construction.

Sources & Media

Media Coverage

Meeting Agenda: